Sort of a late entry for this jim-johnson . . .
MY relationship with violence is probably MY most complex relationship. I am the guy who very gently gets the biker to stop hitting his kid at Walmart. I am also a trainer of trainers for a community called the
Alternative to Violence Project, or AVP volunteering mostly in prison because prison workshops are a good fit for me.
Convicts being truly a captive audience.
The phrase "Trainer of Trainers" is an AVP shorthand, or a fancy way of saying, that I took four AVP workshops and served an apprenticeship as a potential trainer in three more AVP workshops. Though I haven't volunteered very much over this past summer, I will return on a regualr basis soon -- IF only to get tomatoes from Keith and Cynthia.
As a child, I was beaten every day, by both my mother and my father. Very often brutally assaulted.
From eight to fifteen, I regularly suffered contusions, abrasions, broken bones and teeth, and the psychological and emotional abuse attendant to such beatings. I was beaten suddenly, often for little or no reason and with whatever object, tool, or weapon that came to hand, including, but not limited to, hands, fists, belts, shoes, brushes, light cords and ropes, electrical extension cords, rifle barrels, pieces of lumber, sticks, canes, switches, and on one memorable occasion, a bullwhip.
At around age fifteen, or a little before, I became a violent perpertrator myself. I did all the things done to me, and more, to others. Since then I have been shot, stabbed, run over and blown up. I am deeply conversant with violence from both ends of the stick. The simple truth is that IF you put a dog into a cage and poke it with a stick long enough, it will either fight back, or die.
The problem with the "fighting back" theory is that the category "fighting back" gets broader and broader until eventually any kind of violence is justified: Which is how WE got Viet Nam, Bunker Hill, the Battle of the Bulge, and Iraq.
There are no just wars. Not even personal ones.
Though I do believe in self-defense; I do not believe that even self-defense is just, though as a human being, I can
justify most anything.
However, there is no such thing as national defense. What we call national defense is war planning and as Einstein said, "
You cannot simultaneously prevent and prepare for war." WE are a violent, war-like nation not a peaceful one as OUR propaganda suggests. WE almost always begin any international interaction with violence, or the threat of violence, which is the same thing, rather than diplomacy.
This is basically true for most Amerikans on a personal level as well. For most of US, just under OUR surface politeness is a defensive posture waiting to emerge.
Challenge OUR worldview even a little and WE respond with tooth and nail.